There has been much talk recently on a portion of the new book
released based on an interview with Pope Benedict XVI. I have not read
the book, but plan to purchase it this weekend. The media has grabbed a
remark the Pope made about the use of condoms and taken it out of context.
The media wants people to believe that the Pope is starting to alter the
Church's stance on the use of condoms. Why? Because they do not
understand that some people, such as Catholics, believe that marriage is
sacred, that one should not have sex before marriage, that actively preventing
pregnancy, and having an abortion are all wrong. It is totally contrary
to the "norm" of the world (which is one of the sources of
temptation: the world, the flesh, and the devil).
The Pope was using a scenario in which a
possible conversion could occur. Here we have a
male prostitute who uses a condom to stop the spread of HIV. The
Church does not condone prostitution or the use of condoms. However, in
this situation, we have an individual who is committing sins, yet there is
some hope of conversion. He has a concern for his fellow man's well being
(and his own), which could lead to a total transformation of his lifestyle
if that initial, tiny concern for others is fostered. His use of a condom
is still wrong, but it could be a sign that he is concerned about the welfare
of others. Therefore, since he has somewhat of a concern for others,
there is a possibility that he can change.
Take a different scenario. Say you have a "weekend
alcoholic". This person does not drink during the week because it
will interfere with work. However, once 5 pm Friday comes
along, he is not sober again until 9 am Monday (with a hangover). During
the weekend he is abusive to his family and drives drunk. The fact that
he does not allow the alcohol interfere with his work shows that he has a
concern. It might take a good friend to approach him and say something
like, "Hey, you know that you cannot perform at work if you are drinking,
so you do not drink during the week. Can you not also see
is interfering with your family. You need help and I am willing to
help you.” Same thing with the male prostitute. Somebody who knows
him, but is concerned about his soul might say, "You use a condom because
you are concerned about the spread of HIV. Do you not think the better
choice would be to stop it completely?” Of course it would probably
take more than that one statement.
The Pope is not permitting the use of condoms if it is to
stop the spread of HIV. He is saying that the use of condom could be a
signal that this person has a concern for the well being of others and the
beginning of a change if fostered. The Church's teaching on sex is
simple. It is between a married man and woman, open to the conception of a new
life, and without using barriers to prevent conception.
Here is a more complete article about the issue from the National Catholic Register,
ReplyDeletehttp://www.ncregister.com/blog/the-pope-said-what-about-condoms